Bush’s idea of a full and open investigation

This post was written by marc on June 12, 2004
Posted Under: Bush,Politics

Bush promised a “full accounting” for “cruel and disgraceful abuse of Iraqi detainees.” He said the treatment is an “insult to the Iraqi people” and an “affront to the most basic standards of morality and decency.” He said those involved will “answer for their conduct in an orderly and transparent process.”

Document warns Guantanamo employees not to talk

By Toni Locy, USA TODAY

WASHINGTON — Military and civilian employees at the U.S. prison for suspected terrorists at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, were warned recently not to talk with attorneys who represent detainees held there, according to a document prepared by the legal office of the Army-led task force that runs the facility.

The document, obtained by USA TODAY, says that soldiers and interrogators are not required to give defense attorneys statements about the “personal treatment of detainees” or any “failure to report actions of others.” It also says that refusing to cooperate with defense attorneys “will not impact your career.”

The warning — titled “Interaction with Defense Counsel” — has surfaced at a time when the treatment of the nearly 600 detainees at Guantanamo is under scrutiny because of the abuse and sexual humiliation of Iraqis in U.S. custody at the Abu Ghraib prison in Baghdad. Maj. Gen. Geoffrey Miller, former commander at Guantanamo, went to Iraq last year to share interrogation techniques used in Cuba.

A Defense Department spokesman said the document was aimed at ensuring that Guantanamo employees “know what their rights are.” The spokesman said the references to detainee treatment are “relevant examples that make such training better.”

Military law analysts and human rights advocates agree that Guantanamo employees should be advised against making incriminating statements. But they say the advice should be neutral.

The document “suggests that there is something that needs to be hidden” about how detainees are being treated, says Scott Silliman, a Duke University law professor and a former Air Force lawyer. “It suggests that the default should be: Don’t talk.”

Gary Solis, a retired Marine lieutenant colonel, says he gave similar advice to witnesses when he was a military prosecutor. “There’s no impropriety,” says Solis, who teaches law at Georgetown University. But “the context of this advice gives the appearance of encouraging (people) to be less than forthcoming.”

The Pentagon has been secretive about interrogation tactics at Guantanamo, where suspected al-Qaeda and Taliban operatives have been held for more than two years.

President Bush has designated six Guantanamo detainees for trial by military tribunal. Four have been assigned military defense lawyers, who want to question interrogators, soldiers and other detainees. The lawyers want to explore whether evidence against their clients was gathered through abusive tactics. Three of the six detainees have been charged.


Here’s the investigation that Bush promised:

Third, because America’s committed to the equality and dignity of all people, there will be a full accounting for the cruel and disgraceful abuse of Iraqi detainees. Conduct that has come to light is an insult to the Iraqi people and an affront to the most basic standards of morality and decency.

One basic difference between democracies and dictatorships is that free countries confront such abuses openly and directly. In January, shortly after reports of abuse became known to our military, an investigation was launched.

Today, several formal investigations led by senior military officials are under way. Secretary Rumsfeld has appointed several former senior officials to review the investigations of these abuses. Some soldiers have already been charged and those involved will answer for their conduct in an orderly and transparent process.

Reader Comments

unfortunately, defending a prisoner regarding possible terrorist acts and investigating possible criminal behavior on the part of military and subcontracted personnel are not the same. What does Mr. Kerry plan to do if elected?

Written By tenacity on June 12th, 2004 @ 6:25 pm

I remember one quote from Bush; it went something like this – “We’re going to give the Iraqis freedom and they’re gonna like it.”

Written By richard on June 12th, 2004 @ 7:24 pm

Hey, are Cheney and Halliburton already stealing the Iraqis’ oil? We know damn well that every day this war continues, the Carlyle group is making money.

Written By richard on June 12th, 2004 @ 7:52 pm

Given the circumstances around the prisoner abuse and rape the recommendation that troops stay quite does sound suspicious, though.

Written By Shadow Hawk on June 13th, 2004 @ 7:45 pm

LOL. I wondered why the fuel prices are going down a little. They are getting oil.

Written By Dmitri on July 3rd, 2004 @ 10:11 am

Add a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.